Setting up the dream

I’m never quite sure what to expect when I am familiar with a movie before I read the book it was adapted from. I have seen the movie version of the Wizard of Oz many times — I grew up with it, so I was interested in how the book agreed and disagreed with that filmic translation. The movie sets viewers up to recognize similar elements in Oz as we do in Dorothy’s life in Kansas — farm hands become the scarecrow, the tinman, and the cowardly lion, and other characters change form as well. For example, Professor Marvel, the fraud in Kansas, becomes the Wizard of Oz, the essential fraud in Oz. With that, viewers are set up to see Dorothy’s experience as a dream. I expected a similar setup in the novel, which obviously did not occur. However, certain elements created a similar, if less obvious, effect. Everything is gray in Dorothy’s Kansas, even Aunt Em and Uncle Henry — the technicolor that follows, the “lovely patches of green” (18) and “banks of gorgeous flowers” (18) feel vibrant but dreamlike in comparison. Furthermore, the relative calmness of the house in the eye of the storm that rocks the house gently, “like a baby in a cradle” (12) allows for Dorothy to fall “fast asleep” (13). The fact that readers observe Dorothy actually falling asleep in the trancelike rocking surrounded by wailing winds hints at the land of Oz being a part of a dream as well — I’m curious to see how the eventual endings will differ.

One thought on “Setting up the dream

  1. I think it’s really interesting that you mention the set-up for Dorothy at the start of the book. I, too, was surprised at the major differences between book and motion picture. Baum is sly with his creation at the start, as he makes it seemĀ almostĀ that Dorothy isn’t dreaming, because she is awake during the majority of the cyclone. However, right at the end of the scene Dorothy falls asleep. This allows us to question if she is awake or not. I find this to be a very intriguing aspect of Baum’s set-up, because we aren’t totally sure where Oz is situated. Is it another land somewhere in between Earth and the rest of the universe? Or is it all concocted in Dorothy’s head? As you mentioned, we may have to wait and see how the book concludes to make an assessment on whether Dorothy is dreaming. In some ways this ambiguity makes Oz more convoluted, which lends itself well to our discussions of the virtual and the real.

Leave a Reply