I found one of the most intriguing aspects of “Dave’s Neckliss” to be Dave’s personality and character development. Despite facing numerous challenges and injustices, Dave remains a stoic and dignified figure throughout the narrative. He has this ongoing refusal to be cowed by the hostility of his neighbors, which I think really speaks to his resilience and the inner strength he has. In a way, this kind of resilience and inner strength reminded me of Tom’s character in Uncle Tom’s Cabin. However, this resilience comes at a cost for Dave, and his steadfastness ultimately leads to tragic consequences. Clearly, Chesnutt’s portrayal of Dave is very nuanced and multi-faceted. While on the one hand Dave can be seen as a symbol of defiance against this kind of post slavery racial oppression, and his refusal to bow to the expectations of the white community are a form of quiet resistance, his stubbornness and pride also end up being his tragic flaw, leading to his downfall. Does anyone else see parallels to Tom’s character or any others we’ve read about so far?
Dave’s Character
Loading Likes...
Hi Kaitlin! I also noticed comparisons in the characters of Dave and Tom, specifically in their demise despite having strict moral direction throughout their life. While Tom’s use of religion factors into a direct comparison to a Christ-like character, and his tragic death despite remaining true to faith throughout his life, I’d agree that Dave’s experience seems a little less nuanced. Both characters die due to the destructive actions of their slaveowners; Tom being whipped for protecting Cassy and Emmeline and refusing to renounce his faith, and Dave for bearing the brunt of shame and paranoia after wearing the ham. The dramatic deaths of both promote them as martyrs for the cause of honesty and faith. However, I think that Dave’s story centers upon the repercussions of shame rather than the adherence to faith in Tom’s story. I am definitely curious to discuss the Christ comparison tomorrow in-class, and I agree with the comparisons you’ve drawn!